Video lottery does fund K-12 education

I’m running into this again, evidently because the Blue Ribbon panel is meeting on K-12 education across South Dakota. Contrary to the folklore spinning among many, South Dakota’s state law already dedicates nearly all of state government’s share of net machine income from video lottery to property tax reduction. In turn, the money in state government’s property tax reduction is dedicated to “property tax relief through state aid to education.” You can read the two laws here and here in the South Dakota Codified Laws. State government takes half of the money lost by players in the privately owned terminals.

Back in 1994-95, first under acting Gov. Walter Dale Miller and then under elected Gov. Bill Janklow, South Dakota used increases in state government’s share of net machine income to help fund state government and ultimately school-tax relief. Under Janklow, state government’s share of NMI became dedicated to property tax relief, specifically for K-12 education, after South Dakota voters came within a political eyelash of capping the property-tax system in the 1994 general election. The property-tax reduction fund became law in 1996 and the dedication to K-12 property-tax relief became law on Jan. 1, 1997.

You can raise all kinds of arguments about whether the steps taken during Janklow’s third term were the correct ones for property tax relief. But I conducted a simple study during that third term and found two key things: Property taxes collected for K-12 school districts were lower statewide as a result of the relief program; and the sample of individual taxpayers — I used the 105 legislators — showed their school taxes generally were lower too. The goal of the 1995 package was an immediate 20 percent reduction from the 1994 amounts of school taxes. That was essentially achieved. The longer-term goal was 30 percent, and Janklow with the Legislature achieved that goal in his fourth term.

Janklow, a Republican, was emulating the same 30 percent relief goal that the 1994 Democratic team, gubernatorial candidate Jim Beddow and running mate Jim Abbott, had announced first during that campaign. We are now 15 to 20 years after imposition of the caps on school taxes and local property taxes. School boards didn’t adopt tax opt-outs in the fashion that Janklow foresaw; instead, opt-outs seem to be seen as a last resort for them. County commissions likewise have struggled with using tax opt-outs. Voters vary throughout South Dakota but the general pattern seems to be the smaller the opt-out the more likely its passage in a local referendum.

Two big packages of road and bridge funding have come through the Legislature in the past few years to help counties and other local governments, one despite the veto by Gov. Dennis Daugaard and the current one, which had his now second-term support and puts a lot into the state Department of Transportation’s budget too. The Legislature’s Executive Board meanwhile recently selected county funding overall as an interim topic for this summer and fall. The governor’s Blue Ribbon Task Force is gathering opinions city by city and will deliver its report this fall. The Lottery Commission has tried mightily under Daugaard these past four-plus years to generate more revenue from video lottery, with some success, but net machine income remains below its level prior to voters adopting the statewide smoking ban in 2010.

One senses the Janklow-era caps have run their course for many people, but nobody has yet come up with the new funding sources for K-12 and counties. Just three years ago, in the 2012 general election, nearly 57 percent of South Dakota voters opposed an initiated measure that would have added 1 percent of sales tax, with the revenues to be split between Medicaid and K-12 education. There really doesn’t seem to be widespread interest in adding a state general income tax. The Legislature has focused on lower fruit, such as spending the unclaimed-property receipts that legally belong to others but must be remitted to the state treasury for supposed safe-keeping. But if one or two world-level banking corporations leave South Dakota, much of the unclaimed-property stream of revenue dries up when they go.

It will be important to see whether governor’s Blue Ribbon panel comes up with an analysis of how school districts are spending their funding now in comparison to 20-some years ago. Therein might be the telling data. Has the revenue been flowing increasingly into different purposes than pre-1994? And if so, what should be done? And if not, what is the appetite to ask taxpayers for more money?

This entry was posted in SD Government on by .

About Bob Mercer

I am a newspaper reporter in Pierre where I cover state government, issues and politics for the Aberdeen American News, the Black Hills Pioneer, the Mitchell Daily Republic, the Pierre Capital Journal, the Rapid City Journal, the Watertown Public Opinion and the Yankton Press & Dakotan. I began covering the Legislature in 1985 and have lived in Pierre since December 1986. I grew up in Wisconsin, worked my way through college, took my first full-time newspapers jobs in Wyoming, and have lived in South Dakota since the summer of 1984 when I moved to Aberdeen to join the American News. I worked for the Rapid City Journal as its state government reporter in Pierre from late 1992 through late 1998. I spent four years as press secretary and a senior aide to Gov. Bill Janklow during his fourth and final term from late 1998 through 2002. I returned to journalism in January 2003 as a self-employed reporter, providing state government coverage to the Mitchell, Watertown, Spearfish, Pierre and, depending on the year, Aberdeen newspapers. In 2008, the Aberdeen American News offered to hire me as full-time member of the AAN staff, with my reports continuing to be available to the Mitchell, Watertown, Spearfish, Pierre, Yankton and Rapid City papers. The new arrangement has been in effect since January 2009 as the seven papers continue their remarkable dedication to their readers and the general public, as the only South Dakota news outlets with a full-time reporter covering state government in Pierre throughout the year. In addition to focusing on the Legislature during the annual winter session and its various activities during the interim periods between sessions, I spend many days throughout the year -- traveling as often necessary -- to cover state government boards and commissions which oversee the state universities, technical institutes, outdoors, water, environment, business, public schools, banking, agriculture, utilities, health care and various other areas of public interest. I purposely don't register to vote because of my profession; the last time I recall voting in a presidential election was the first time, 1976, when I had just turned 18. I think I voted for Jimmy Carter over Gerald Ford. Make of that what you want, just don't make much of it.

Leave a Reply